Protecting Accident Victims Throughout Western Pennsylvania.

Call 412-391-6636 for a free case consultation.

THE HOMYAK LAW FIRM, P.C.

Protecting Accident Victims Throughout Western Pennsylvania.

Proving “constructive notice” in premises liability cases

On Behalf of | Apr 22, 2025 | Personal Injury

Slip and fall accidents can happen in an instant, but proving fault takes more than pointing to a puddle or loose tile. Property owners must keep their spaces reasonably safe, especially for visitors and customers. If someone gets hurt, the injured person must show the owner knew or should have known about the hazard, which is where the idea of “constructive notice” becomes important.

What constructive notice means

In Pennsylvania, “constructive notice” means a property owner should have known about a dangerous condition, even if they didn’t actually see it themselves. The law expects owners to regularly inspect their property and fix or warn about problems. If a hazard exists for a long time and no one fixes it, the court may decide the owner had contributory negligence and is liable for damages.

For example, if a shopper slips on a spill two minutes after it happens, the store may not have had enough time to clean it up. On the other hand, if the spill sits for 30 minutes, the store should have noticed and cleaned it. The longer a hazard stays in place, the stronger the case for constructive notice.

Photos, surveillance videos, and witness statements often help prove how long a hazard existed. Maintenance records or a lack of them also come into play if they can prove that the owner failed to do routine safety checks.

How someone can show that the owner should have known

To build a strong case, the injured person must collect evidence that shows the hazard was visible and avoidable:

  • Was the danger in a high-traffic area?
  • Would a simple inspection have caught it?
  • Did the property owner ignore past complaints about the same issue?

If a business often ignores spills or broken flooring, that pattern of neglect supports constructive notice. If a worker walks past a spill without cleaning it or warning others, that type of employee behavior also shows the business failed to act.

Witnesses who saw the hazard before the accident can also support the claim. Their testimony can show that the danger was out in the open and not hidden or hard to spot.

A clear understanding of constructive notice helps injured people focus on the right facts for a strong case. It shifts attention to the property owner’s actions and whether they kept their space safe over time.